The Power of Education
Updated: Oct 7
When learning how the Town has been underestimating revenue to boost Free Cash, I am reminded of another situation where revenue was going to significantly exceed budget estimates and the Town wanted it increase to go to Free Cash.
Some background first. A few years into Brad Crozier's tenure as Superintendent of Sudbury Public Schools, he started publishing an annual Budget Book and presenting the district's goals in layers of priority. Base Tier was the minimum to satisfy contractual obligations. Tier 1 were priority items. Tier 2 were development ideas. Covering the Base Tier and some of Tier 1 usually fit into the budget. Tier 2 were strategic initiatives waiting for funding.
Education is one of the main reasons families move to Sudbury. And, as such, the Superintendent and his team hold real power when it comes to our taxes. The fact is, if they claim that education is going to suffer without a tax override, then the voters are going to show up and support. Sudbury prioritizes family and education. So, you always wonder if they will actually work to stay within budgets or if they might just wield their sword and ask for more money because they can.
I started working closely with members of the SPS team back in 2018 when we collaborated to modernize our elementary school playgrounds. This was a 4-5 year project (which included the Covid years), so I had a front seat view of the team. And what I discovered was that this team took financial responsibility VERY seriously. I saw them clean up the school budgets and bring better process to the finance piece. They respected the tax payer dollar as if it were their own.
As a result, there were always things in the Tier 2 (and sometimes Tier 1) priorities that just weren't funded because they didn't think an override was justified. But they still developed Tier 2 ideas just in case. Well, a few years ago there was a "just in case" moment.
In the 2023, Governor Healey signed an unprecedented increase in state aid for schools. The Chapter 70 funds (named after the section of Mass. General Law pertaining to school funding) were going to significantly exceed estimates. But, by the time the funds were finalized at the State Level, Sudbury had already passed a budget using the lower Chapter 70 estimate. Had SPS known that Chapter 70 was going to be higher, they would have had further discussion about the possibilities of more Tier 1 and possibly Tier 2 initiatives and probably increased the school budget as a result.
Once it was announced that the money was definitely headed our way, the schools were definitely interested in the funds. However, since the school budget had already been voted by Town Meeting (State and Local budget processes are notorious for being completely misaligned in timing) the schools would only be able to utilize the funds if Town Meeting voted to increase the school budget allocation.
The town management wasn't interested in giving that option to the voters. The Select Board and town management were adamant that the extra funds should flow to Free Cash instead of to the schools. Luckily, the Superintendent and his team were able to mobilize support from the community and put an article in the Special Town Meeting for the fall of 2023 to increase the school budget and allow our students to benefit from the increase in State Aid. The Select Board was so adamant in their opposition that the Chair read a statement at Town Meeting criticizing the schools leaders.
We were lucky to have a school leadership team who stood up to the Town Manager and Select Board in order to best serve the students of Sudbury. Was this a reason why the Superintendent was pushed out of town? In my opinion (and I'll emphasize that this is my opinion), absolutely. Like I said earlier, the Schools hold great power in Sudbury when it comes to raising taxes. And if the Town is interested in raising taxes for non-school purposes, they know that they have a better chance of getting that override passed if they can also claim that education will suffer without it. Having a Superintendent who respected the tax payers and pushed back on a Town Manager and Select Board instead of just "going along with their plans" was great for us as tax payers, but perhaps a thorn in the side of the town management.
The school leadership has changed. Not only has Brad been removed, but the Director of Finance is on leave. What's going to happen in this year's budget discussions? Your guess is as good as mine.


