Is it the Truth or Politics?
Following my stream of consciousness from yesterday . . . I was thinking about the salary increase that the Town negotiated with teachers. Look, I believe that our town staff (teachers included) should be making reasonable salaries. In fact, let's be honest, many people move here for the great schools and public services, so we should probably be in the upper quadrant of the salary ranges? But I'm not here to debate that.
All town employees should be treated fairly when it comes to salary, and no one group should be treated differently just because they might be a stronger political entity. And I think that's what was giving me the ick factor yesterday when I was learning about the special clause in the teacher contracts which promised them a 2% raise if the town approved an override. Why only the teachers? What about the other town employees?
While I was on the Finance Committee (2018-2022) and as a Library Trustee (2022-2025) I was concerned about whether town employee salaries were where they should be. Most employees are in unions, so I hoped that their union negotiations would bring decent contracts. However, there are a handful of town staff who are not in unions (Goodnow Library staff are part of this group), so they don't have a union negotiating on their behalf.
While on the Finance Committee, I asked the Town Manager when the last time a salary comparison survey had been done for library staff and other non-union employees. At the time, he answered that it had been done in the past couple of years - placing a study in the 2018-2021-ish timeframe. Unfortunately, the Town was unwilling to share the study.
In subsequent years as a Goodnow Library Trustee, I worked with the library director to do our own informal salary survey. The results were disappointing. The library staff was grossly underpaid vs comparable towns. See this link for details - Goodnow Library FY25 Budget Presentation. But this was met by the town administration with no action. And I don't recall any Select Board or Finance Committee member even taking notice.
This year, as the Town is purporting the need for an override, they suddenly told the library and other non-union staff that they were going to conduct a salary survey. They said that the last survey had occurred in 2014.
2014? What? The Town had earlier told the Finance Committee that they had done a study in the 2020-ish timeframe. The one that they were unwilling to share with the Finance Committee.
Sigh. Where was the truth?
Disappointed (although not surprised) that no study had been done before. And disappointed that, despite years of the library director and trustees bringing this issue to the Town/Select Board/Finance Committee, no movement was ever offered.
So why now? Did they suddenly wake up to the fact that these employees were probably underpaid? Or were they looking for a reason to justify an override?
And then to see that the Town had offered the teachers a guaranteed salary increase if an override were to pass. Why wasn't such an offer made to the library and other non-union staff? Was any such offer made to the police, fire, or DPW departments?
While I don't necessarily agree with the clause in the teachers contract which ties raises to an override vote, I definitely don't agree that some employees were given that option but others were not. Why were the teachers given a 2% salary guarantee if an override were to pass but others weren't? Could it have anything to do with the power that a teacher's voice has over parents?
Seriously. What. Is. Going. On.
P.S. I'll just reiterate here that I think that if we fixed the underestimation of tax revenue and over budgeting of expenses, we could easily bring salaries of the non-union employees up without an override. The increase proposed by the library a few years ago would have only cost about $50,000 for the library staff portion.


